Saturday, April 9, 2016

Diversity & Science Fiction (Part II: A Case study of Star Wars)

(Via)

In July of 1977 the LA Times published an article entitled  "The Great White Void" by Raymond St. Jacques, a black actor and director. In it James critiqued the fact that while science fiction was supposed to be free "from worry about acceptive norms of our present racist society". But instead, popular science fiction films like 2001: A Space Odyssey, Logan's Run and Star Wars were nearly devoid of African-American actors and actresses. In the weeks ahead the Times would publish letters to the editor in response of Jacques.  One of these was by a reader, Linda Buzzwell, who added on to Jacques observations, saying: "there are no women pilots, soldiers, or other professionals" in Star Wars.  Despite this, Buzzwell had seen the film five times. The same number, as it happens, as Jacques.

Thursday, April 7, 2016

On Diversity & Science Fiction (Part I)

The first Star Wars: Rouge One trailer dropped today.  You should it see it. Go, right now. I don't mind.  Its awesome. In response to the film's main protagonist seemingly being a woman (played by Felicity Jones) conservative luminary John Podhoretz, film critic for the Weekly Standard  tweeted (and quickly deleted) this 'joke'

(Via)

Monday, March 28, 2016

Grappling With Vigilantism: A Review of Jessica Jones & Daredevil (Part II)

(Here be spoilers)
Fred punches me in the face and walks away. Do I: A -report Fred to the police and hope he is arrested for assault- or B -ask my my masked vigilante friend to beat him up? How one answers that question has important implications for the role of the state in your life.  To explain why, and how superheroes fit into all of this, you have to understand the idea of a "Monopoly on Force"

Saturday, March 26, 2016

One Bad Day: A Review of Jessica Jones and Daredevil (Part I)

(Here be Spoliers for Jessica Jones and Daredevil)



Early on in season two of Daredevil The Punisher and our titular hero have a discussion about morality. Matt's a Catholic, The Punisher used to be. Matt argues that his absolute prohibition on killing is justified because  "everyone deserves a chance at redemption".  The Punisher counters by saying that not all people can be redeemed, and that killing people before they have a chance to kill others is the utilitarian thing to do. The Punisher then sets up a twisted version of the Trolley Problem. Daredevil can kill the Punisher, and save who he was about to kill, or not kill the Punisher and allow him to kill.  Matt chooses a third option, but despite his best efforts someone still dies. During the confrontation the Punisher declares "One bad day and you'd be just like me!" He's wrong, Matthew Murdock has had bunch of bad days. From loosing his sight to losing his father, Matt has had more then his share of misery.

Saturday, February 27, 2016

The Case for Bernie Part IV (on feminism and other concerns)

I could say more about Hillary's non progressive record (The Patriot ActSexual and reproductive health! a live and let live attitude towards Wall Street!) but there is really no point, Hillary is basically a moderate-to-conservative Democrat, and from a left wing policy position is bad.

Friday, February 26, 2016

The Case for Bernie (Part III, or: 1,846,850 Children)

Now, you may be be thinking,  Jacob, while that last section was certainly interesting, you seem to be conflating Hillary with her husband, isn't that pretty sexist? You're absolutely right, it would pretty sexist, Hillary is her own person after all!  The problem with this argument is that the Clintons were always a team. Hillary encouraged Bill's mind meld with the DLC, and is actually the more conservative of the two. A close friend of hers once noted "It’s not true that she is the liberal one... the idea is that you work for everything, she believes in personal responsibility" Therefore its totally valid for a critique of Hillary to include the skeletons of the first Clinton administration.

And what skeletons they were! The 1994 Crime bill . (Honesty forces me to point out that Sanders voted for it as a member of the House- but specifically because of its Violence Against Women provisions- and was opposed to most everything else) DADT, DOMA, Iraqi Sanctions, Economic Deregulation, but I want to focus more in depth on one aspect of the Clinton record: The 1996 Welfare Reform Act.